Attracting Excellence: Top Tips for Recruiting Great Teachers
The impact of great teachers goes beyond test scores. They bring new energy, unique strengths, unparalleled expertise and incredible teamwork. A school is only as strong as the people leading the classrooms!
But attracting top talent doesn’t happen by accident. It takes careful thought and a school culture that educators will love. When the right teachers join your team, your community will change in the best possible ways.
Showcase your school’s culture
Great teachers want to feel like they belong. Highlight what makes your school unique—your mission, values, traditions and everyday wins. Share photos, stories and testimonials to help candidates picture themselves as part of your team from the very beginning.
Offer mentorship and support
Show candidates exactly what support looks like—scheduled check-ins, reliable mentors and a solid onboarding plan. With a clear system in place, candidates are much more likely to say “yes” to the job!
Promote opportunities for growth
Highlight opportunities to advance their careers. They could lead a committee, present at a conference or earn PD credits through district workshops. Educators want to work at a school that allows them to grow their teaching skills and take on roles beyond the classroom.
Be transparent about expectations
Spell out the job details, including class sizes, curriculum, schedule and additional duties. Being clear and upfront helps candidates decide if it’s the right fit and builds trust before they even step through the door. No surprises, just honest communication.
Use social media to your advantage
Post classroom highlights, give teachers a shoutout or share behind-the-scenes moments that let your school’s personality shine through. A photo or brief video can give candidates a real feel for the energy you’re proud of!
Create a positive interview experience
Greet candidates warmly, and leave room for their questions, not just yours! A well-run, respectful interview shows you value their time—and sets the tone for what it’s like to work at your school.
Follow up and stay connected
Don’t let great candidates disappear. Send a thoughtful follow-up email, even if they weren’t the right fit this time around. Checking in down the road could lead to your next amazing hire!
Who will you hire next?
Teachers want more than a job that pays the bills. They want a job that makes them feel valued, supported and inspired to keep growing. Lead with your school’s unique culture, and the right people will take notice. Build the kind of place educators are proud to call home!

Published by:
Joe Donovan
Founding Partner and President, Donovan Group